Mathematics of Language: Errors
List of Errors
- Page 83 The sentence Notice that the edge colours
only the vertex colours are used to steer the derivation.
is not grammatical and misleading. It should read instead
Notice that only the edge colours are used to steer the
derivation. (This has been spotted by John Colby.)
- Seite 108, (2.22)On the left hand side it must read
A &u2192; a
. (This has been spotted by Christian
Wurm.)
- Page 295 Exercise 141. I have grossly underestimated
the status of Leibniz' Principle in set theory. It comes down
to the identity of indiscernibles. Set theory with Leibniz'
Principle has been studied by Jan Mycielski. The structure
theory of such universes is everything but easy, see Ali Enayat:
"Leibnizian models of set theory",
The Journal of Symbolic Logic 69, 2004, 757 - 789.
- Page 409. Theorem 5.45 ist false for k ≥ 3. This
is the result of Makoto Kanazawa, Gregory M. Kobele, Jens
Michaelis, Sylvain Salvati and Ryo Yoshinaka: The Failure of
the Strong Pumping Lemma for Multiple Context-Free Languages
(unpublished manuscript).
- Page 425-426 Die claim that indexed grammars can only generate
PTIME languages has been refuted by Bill Rounds in 1973
("Complexity in Recognition in Intermediate-Level Languages",
in: Proceedings 14th Annual IEEE Symposium on Switching and
Automata Theory, 145 - 158. IEEE Computer Science,
Northridge, CA). (Thanks for Hans-Jörg Thiede for
spotting this.)
- Page 470 Definition 6.2 should contain the clause that
L is not empty.
- Page 472 The claim that MSO can differentiate between
a class that contains the empty word and this class without the
empty word is false. This does hold however for QML.
Adding the condition that L is not empty the problem
will disappear. (Geoffrey Pullum has noticed this.)
- Page 502 The claim that a transducer can be made
deterministic is of course false. The implicit use of the
analogous fact for finite automata is not licit. The problem
is that while strings have a unique decomposition into letters,
pairs of strings do not have such a decomposition. For example
the pair ⟨a, a⟩ has two decompositions into a product
of the pairs ⟨a : ε⟩ or ⟨ε : a⟩.
- Page 520, Example (6.172) This sentence is not
grammatical. It should read
John is believed to be responsible for himself.
Marcus Kracht
Last changed: Thu April 19, 2012 14:30:00